Nobody Inside Has Asked

Walt keeps taking two buses to see his daughter, until an officer tells him why he should stop coming.

A story inspired by real events

Listen to this Chronicle, narrated by a synthetic voice.

When the officer came out from behind the glass, Walt stood up and reached for his locker key.

“Leave your coat,” she said.

He let go of the key. It swung against his belt.

For six weeks, someone at that window had told him he couldn’t go in. Now Officer Achebe was on his side of the glass, holding the door open behind her.

He could hear people farther inside. A woman laughing. A chair scraping.

“Am I going through?”

“No,” she said. “I’m coming out.”

The door shut with a heavy click.

Walt sat.

Across the lobby, a little boy was trying to push two bags of chips into the same pocket. His grandmother pulled one out and carried it for him. The door buzzed, and they went through.

Walt watched until it closed.

Officer Achebe sat two chairs away. Up close, she looked younger than she did behind the window.

“Mr. Brennan,” she said.

“Walt.”

“Walt. I’m Simone.”

He nodded, careful not to look pleased. First names seemed like progress.

“I know you take the bus,” she said.

“Two.”

“And you leave work early.”

“Roofing. Can’t do much after dark anyway.”

That wasn’t true. There was always something to load or cover or haul away. His boss had stopped asking where he went on Thursdays. Now he just looked at the clock.

Walt rubbed his shoulder through his shirt.

“If this is about last week,” he said, “I wasn’t yelling at that girl. I know how my voice gets.”

“It’s not about that.”

“I brought what she told me to bring.”

“I know.”

“So what’s missing?”

The vending machine hummed beside them. Something inside it knocked three times, then stopped.

“Your permission to visit had an end date,” Simone said. “It ended.”

“Yes. That’s what they keep saying.”

“Casey has to ask to have you back.”

“Then tell her.”

“She knows how.”

“No, tell her I’m here.”

Simone rested her hands on her knees.

Walt leaned toward her.

“She’s nineteen. You can explain a thing to her and she’ll say she understands, then it turns out she’s heard about half of it.”

He waited for a smile. He usually got one with that. Parents knew.

Simone didn’t smile.

“The first time I came,” Walt said, “she asked if I’d had trouble finding the place. Like she was having me over.”

He looked at the locked door.

“She’s funny.”

“I can’t discuss Casey with you.”

“I’m not asking you to.”

But he was, and they both knew it.

He sat back. There was a white mark on his work pants where he’d knelt in something that morning. He scratched at it with his thumbnail.

They had talked about ordinary things during those first visits. Her shoes hurt. His upstairs neighbor had bought a drum set. She wanted to know if the dog still slept under the kitchen table.

He’d said yes, though the dog slept by the front door now.

On his last visit, Casey had asked about a school play.

“The one where I was a tree,” she’d said.

“You were a good tree.”

“You didn’t come.”

He had laughed before he understood she wasn’t joking.

Then he’d tried to remember why. A job running late. His truck. Something with her mother.

Casey had watched him search.

At the end, he’d said, “Well, I’m here now.”

She had picked a loose thread from her sleeve.

Walt turned toward Simone.

“Just renew it. Write me in. Five minutes, I’m not dangerous.”

“I don’t renew anything by hand. Not for you, not for anybody.”

“You could open that door.”

“Yes,” she said. “I could.”

He hadn’t expected her to admit it.

“Then let me sit with her. You can stand right there.”

“No.”

“I’m her father.”

“I know.”

He pressed his good hand over his mouth. He needed a minute before speaking again.

“You got kids?”

“Yes.”

“Then you know.”

Simone looked down at her hands.

“I know it’s hard to go home.”

That nearly undid him. He’d been ready for another explanation, something he could argue with. He looked away.

The grandmother and the little boy would be sitting down by now. Opening chips. Asking questions. Somebody would get crumbs on the table.

“I come every week,” Walt said.

“I’ve seen you.”

“Rain. That sleet we had.”

“Yes.”

“I thought if somebody saw I was serious.”

“I do see.”

“Then help me.”

Simone drew a breath.

“I came out here to ask you to stop coming.”

He stared at her.

“Until your permission is renewed,” she said.

“How’s she supposed to know I’m serious if I stop?”

Simone let the question sit between them.

Walt heard footsteps behind the glass. Another officer passed through the desk area carrying a mug.

“I checked before I came out,” Simone said. “Casey hasn’t asked for you to visit again.”

His thumb stopped scraping at the white mark.

“Maybe she forgot.”

“Maybe.”

“Maybe she thinks she did.”

“I don’t know what she thinks.”

“Then you don’t know.”

“No,” Simone said. “I don’t.”

He wanted her to argue. He could have stayed angry a little longer.

Instead, she sat beside him while the machine hummed.

After a while, he said, “It shouldn’t run out. A father.”

“Your visits were allowed for a set time. That time ended. She gets to ask again.”

“She asked before.”

“Yes.”

He looked at the door. For weeks he had pictured Casey on the other side of it, waiting for someone to fix whatever was keeping him out.

He tried to picture her doing something else.

Eating supper. Washing her hair. Sitting with her hands in her lap, knowing Thursday had come.

He couldn’t get far with it.

“I missed a lot,” he said.

Simone stayed quiet.

“Birthdays. Things at school. I always called after.”

His shoulder ached. He lowered his hand into his lap.

“I thought I could quit being that guy.”

The door buzzed. Walt looked up before he could help it.

A woman came out carrying an empty cloth bag. She stopped at the lockers, put on a red hat, and left.

Walt watched the loose end of her scarf disappear through the outside door.

“Doesn’t mean never,” he said.

“No,” Simone said. “It doesn’t mean never.”

She went back to the desk after that. Walt stayed in his chair.

He missed one bus. Then another.

At last, he got up and opened his locker. His coat was cold against his arms. He worked his bad shoulder into the sleeve, shut the little door, and put the key back in its slot.

Simone looked up through the glass.

“Okay,” he said. “I’ll wait at home, then.”

Outside, the parking lot shone under the lights. Walt zipped his coat and walked toward the bus stop without looking back.

The next visiting day, Simone glanced across the lobby when the door opened.

A woman came in, stamping snow from her boots.

Walt’s chair stayed empty.


About this story. Inspired by real events. The people, places and details are invented.